Tuesday, 26 October 2021

Reflections on a lifelong journey of reclaiming the street

It's Thursday evening and I just got back from a run. It’s just before 6pm; still light but getting dark. I’ve had my head in Twitter for the past 24 hours, absorbing post after post of women sharing their lived experience of walking alone on streets (and some posts from men offering ally support). I find myself contemplating the route I just chose to run. I tend to change my running routes often and I don’t put a lot of thought into them beyond distance, so they tend to include ‘following my nose’ to a certain extent. This evening’s run took me through a fairly large, post-industrial wasteland-cum-park in north Glasgow, followed by streets in a local neighbourhood with one of the highest general crime rates in Glasgow. I often run here - I don’t think i’ve ever seen anyone else running in either the neighbourhood or the park. But they’re just streets - ordinary people’s neighbourhoods. 

The route wasn’t deliberate, exactly. But actually maybe on some subconscious level it was. A reaction, at least, to everything i’ve been reading all day. Woman after woman pointing out the steps they have to take every single day to make themselves slightly safer and asking others [men] to be aware of their impact in public space. So many things I can identify with. 

I spend a lot of my time out walking, running and cycling alone on urban streets. I research streets. My professional life revolves around advising on the safe design of streets. Urban space is a significant part of my emotional and physical life. I have been aware for a long time (perhaps because of this work) that I occupy and embody public space differently to most women (and indeed, most men) that I know. The “reclaim the street” movement has always been hugely important to me and I see my role in that as one of enabling, trailblazing perhaps. I go out walking, running, cycling - I confidently occupy physical urban space - in part so I can empower others [women] to do so. 

And what’s my main tool for doing that - for assertively reclaiming the street? Actually, it’s smiling at people. I pretty much always, when passing someone coming towards me, make deliberate eye contact and smile at them. It sounds odd but on reflection, this is the way I assert my confidence. It unnerves people sometimes; it gently tells them i’ve clocked them; it transmits to them that I am aware of, and in control of, my situation. Some smile back, which is nice. Many don’t. But it takes out the opportunity for people [men] to make comments at me. It’s a subtle, gentle way of going on the offensive. 

But I need to be very clear that I do this despite fear. When i’m out walking or running, i’m constantly risk assessing, constantly playing scenarios in my mind about being attacked so I can be as ready as possible with my physical response. I was mugged at gunpoint when I was 20, along with two friends - proper up against the wall with a shotgun in the back of my neck type stuff. I think this event probably shaped my fear response over the years, in that it galvanised my belief in my right to reclaim the street. In the days after that event, when I was paralysed with fear, I really had to make myself go back out at night and i’m so glad 20-year-old me did. (Interestingly, i’m terrified of taxis - I wouldn’t get in a taxi on my own if you paid me.) 

The truth is, I simply cannot afford to allow fear to change my behaviour. If on any tiny level I had changed my running route this evening ‘because of Sarah Everard’ (and/or any other of the thousands of women in her position), that would have been the start of an undermining of my ability to go out and do what I do: occupy public streets when and how I want to. In a sense, every solo walk, every solo run, every solo cycle is a small protest. I simply refuse to give in. Whilst also noting that this very sentiment is indicative of the fear-induced scenario that I and so many other women live with daily. I’m just able/choosing perhaps to deal with it slightly differently - this is not intended to sound in any way arrogant. 

And I have huge privilege within this. I’m relatively tall, for a woman, relatively fit and strong, and practised at being confident on my own. I practised this over the years because it matters to me. Which is not to say i’m not careful. Of course I am. I take the same precautions anyone [any man] would take when going out - this is not me wishing to belittle or undermine anyone else’s experiences.  

Lastly, to speak briefly to the ‘not all men’ response: I hear you and yes, this is important. (I am often “not all women”.) I want you to feel heard. But we all have to examine our privilege, me included. As a woman, I am rarely (if ever, I think) a threat to other women. I can make eye contact, pass without having to cross the road etc - although I often do if i’m coming up behind a woman at night, as men are being asked to do. I could even walk a woman home without it being creepy. But I am also careful in some areas about running behind people, men included. The sound of running feet is very different in a lycra-clad, middle class community compared to the fear response it might trigger in an area with higher street crime rates. I am also white, therefore inheriting all the inherent privilege of being white in public space, most of which i’m sure i’m not even aware of. We all have to be aware of our impact on others in public space, however inadvertent it might. 

I weep with Sarah’s family and friends, as I weep with [female] friends who constantly alter and limit their lives to account for the toxic effects of gender-based violence. I will continue to do what I can to resist in my personal life. And to try to bring about liberation and change through my professional work. Let’s not fail to recognise these issues for the desperately difficult things that they are. But let’s also recognise our individual propensity to effect change and make sure there are safe channels for [men] to understand how they can also help to do that. 


COP-wrestling

Yes, it's another blogpost about COP... Sorry, not sorry. This one, however, is my very raw attempt to work through my muddied, complex and challenging feelings about COP, specifically as a resident of Glasgow. These have been brewing for a while now and have culminated in a sort of sceptic-laced misery-grump iteration of me who is swirling around in an increasingly disempowered pseudo-rant. Whilst this is a true and very real me at the moment, I fear it's not really a me that my future self will be proud of (and I surely owe her the chance to say she turned up, at least). 

So I took myself on a cycle pilgrimage this afternoon - to create a deliberate, roving space for reflection - with a view to seeing if I could shift my mindset into something more constructive ahead of COP. One of the things I paused to do was flick through Twitter (an oft-performed act which can tend towards sapping energy, rather than giving it) and I encountered a few other folk there asking various iterations of the "am I alone in finding COP difficult?" question. So I guess it feels worth taking a moment to e-pen these thoughts and insights, and to wrestle them into something I can throw out to the universe. Here goes: 

"My" Glasgow isn't the Glasgow i'm seeing portrayed to the world 
This is a biggie, with layers of complexity within (because who ever has the right to say what a place is and isn't - I can only offer my thoughts). I met a good friend the other evening who I rely heavily upon for helping me sort out muddied thoughts and giving me different ways of seeing the world. He's Glaswegian in a way i'm not (i'm an "immigrant" here, technically, but I have chosen to commit to this place that I love deeply and it has graciously taken me in...) We were talking about the way in which Glasgow is being represented, externalised to the world at the moment. The city has a long history of branding and re-branding, selling and re-selling. A habit that perhaps speaks to an underlying insecurity that what it is, who it is, isn't "enough" somehow. A habit that is in overdrive at the moment, with COP approaching.
An outstretched hand containing a pile of wild raspberries in the foreground against a backdrop of a metal fence and two white, high-rise blocks of flats
But actually, scratch the surface and you'll find an integrity in the city and in its people that will far outlast any short-lived marketing campaign. An integrity that is of Glasgow but which somehow seems to lose trust in itself as it migrates up the echelons. Wander any of the myriad of Glasgow's streets and you will very much get "warts and all", even in the more sanitised areas of the city. Clearly, this is far from ideal. Glasgow is a place of extreme deprivation by Western standards, starkly "cheek by jowl" in terms of how affluence and poverty sit together at two ends of the same street in places. It's a complex, living city with an epidemic level of car-sickness which is literally killing its most vulnerable residents, all a product of a physical violence inflicted by the past powers that were. 

But that is what and who it is as a city. And it is beautiful in its complexity because it is above all real. What better place therefore to demonstrate the challenges, juxtapositions and battles of the reality of dealing with broader sustainability and climate-related crises? What better model than one that is making attempts to battle some of the highest air pollution levels in Europe, alongside inefficient and crumbling housing stock and a legacy of public health problems and (in all honesty) utterly failing at times to do so? But that will only work if the leaders (and citizens) are willing to be vulnerable and honest about how things really are. Surely the one thing Glasgow is owed is its integrity on the world stage? And surely it is here, in honesty and vulnerability, that leadership could truly be shown? 

I haven't actually made the time to engage with COP 
This was a fairly key realisation. I'm a big picture person, apt to form lasting opinions about things without really making the time to engage properly (partly because I get overwhelmed by how much there is to engage with). Luckily it's simple enough to fix! But my learning here is that i'd been treating COP as one giant, impenetrable megalith whereas I think I can engage with it much better if I take time to understand the detail of what's involved. 

My little corner of the world is unlikely to change (spoiler: no one's is) 
The reality is that on 14 November, when the Bigwigs have gone home, there will still be a 12-lane motorway going through the centre of Glasgow, kids will still be breathing in illegal levels of air pollution whilst walking to school and we'll still be trumpeting e-vehicles as the miracle cure for all ills (whilst lie-ridden car adverts continue to fill the increasingly prolific digital advertising boards festooning what was once the public realm...) The point of a global conference like this is not really to make substantial, immediate change. If change occurs (and I hope it will), it will not directly be the result of COP but rather the actions of individuals and groups in the wake of something that will, at the very least, provide some sort of shockwave through the system. 

In a sense, relying on COP itself to make change happen is a form of self-laziness; i'd rather COP did the dirty work for me, rather than having to engage with that myself. But this is where the agency thing comes in, I guess. All I can do is keep identifying my little corner and the agency I do have. The hard neither starts nor ends after COP, it will merely continue. And if we're very lucky, the framework it continues in might have shifted slightly for the better. But I think whilst we can hope for that, we need not to rely on it. 

I am already feeling overwhelmed and ineffective and this isn't helping 
I was reading a tweet from another friend earlier about what it is to work in anything to do with sustainability (especially transport and/or climate change more broadly), how easy it is to burn out, how ineffective (if reassuring) the echo chamber can be. In the quieter moments (such as today) when I take time to engage with how i'm really feeling, I find a deep, nagging sense of overwhelm and ineffectiveness that sits just below my emotional surface the majority of the time. And yes, before you ask, leaving a practitioner-focussed job and doing a PhD hasn't helped with this particular aspect! 

What COP is doing (I think) is poking at those uncomfortable feelings because it's drawing yet more attention to the scale of the problem (i'm well aware, thank you) and the more apathetic i'm getting, the more ineffective and overwhelmed i'm feeling. This is partly a big picture person problem. I would do well to just delineate what my little corner of the world is and (crucially) where its boundaries lie. I was sat the other day on a giant round hay bale with a close friend. We were commenting on how much the bale weighed (probably not far short of half a tonne) and yet it consisted purely of individual bits of grass, each weighing almost nothing. Every little thing matters, every little action (good or bad!) adds up to a whole. I feel it's so, so crucial to hang onto that visual aid...
A row of cylindrical haybales against a backdrop of a field, dark blue sea and a light blue sky with white clouds
This isn't about me 
My cycle ride today took me out east, through several areas of the city that have been subject to years and years of under-investment and bear witness to this. There was a deliberateness to this routing (as there always is when i'm choosing where to travel through and to on my bike-potters), relating to the integrity issue above. Now, I will not for one moment claim to be in any way "of" the more deprived places in Glasgow - I have none of that lived experience and far be it from me to be seen to be somehow romanticising something that's not mine. But I do routinely take myself to and through places that the beaten track tends to avoid, because they are of Glasgow and ultimately they are just places belonging to people. 

Today, my journeying was hugely helpful in terms of literally taking me out of the West End, away from the UN flags and banners (notably absent east of the city centre), to something much more indicative of 'real' Glasgow, in all its fullness. To ask: "what is COP here?" where life expectancy is in the mid-60s and worklessness rates some of the highest in the UK. What is COP for the kids I passed playing out in the large swathe of derelict land behind the flats, some lighting a fire near a fly-tip site, some giving backies on bikes, some smoking fags against the playground fence... I don't know, is the answer. Because I don't think those narratives readily make it into the mainstream. It is (I think) both my responsibility and obligation to use my platform, my resources and my privilege because it just isn't about me (and it's probably not about you either). 

I don't know how to deal with the privilege of living in the "host" city 
All this, and yet here I am living in Glasgow with this great [potentially] world-changing thing happening on my doorstep, with half the world coming to visit. Surely the least I can do is turn up? But how to hold and be true to the despair, the reality, the hopelessness that still permeates? I feel it doesn't do to bottle these things up. That's perhaps a live question to continue to grapple with... But recognising the privilege of living here and calling this amazing city home as the world descends for a couple of weeks is perhaps a start.

And for what it's worth, here's a little list of actions i'm going to attempt to engage with (shared in case they're of use to others):

- Find ways to represent "my" Glasgow: visually, in conversation, via twitter... for no reason other than it feeling like an important thing to offer into the ether
- Identify just one thing each day (from the huge pile of potential things) to go to and properly engage with, online or in person, and if I don't make it then that's fine
- Try to recycle one piece of learning or new insight per day via Twitter 
- Take myself out into the "real" world to engage with a non-academic, non-structured practice - probably walking, probably cycling, probably staring at pavements or finding high places (which give a different perspective) 
- Above all, listen and learn (rather than 'give' or 'teach' etc)